Peanut Butter Cookies made fresh! Soft, large Peanut Butter Cookies are 4 ounces (quarter pound!) in size. Every order has the option of a free custom greeting card if you want to send them as a gift. Our recipe does not follow the norm in cookie recipes. These have a very strong peanut butter flavor, and we bake at a very low temperature, which allows the cookies to bake through to the center, but then the edges are not burned at all. If you want to break one to dunk in milk, you will find that the will bend more than break and you probably more “tear” the cookie. But the moisture of our cookies won't really allow them to soak up too much milk! We're just emphasizing how soft and chewy they are and we hope this gives you an accurate sense of our product. Of course, we suggest you just try them!
Our big, chewy Peanut Butter Cookie is our second best seller. It took awhile to pin down the exact combination of baking soda and baking powder to get these to spread, rise and hold together. But we did it! They are rich and chewy with a blast of peanut butter flavor.